Employment Termination Decision Upheld Despite Lack of Internal Investigation

By Jonathan Ablett | November 26, 2017

Watkins v. Willow Park Golf Course Ltd, 2017 ABQB

The issue of termination of employment for just cause was considered in this case by Justice Hollins of the Alberta Court of Queens Bench.

Interestingly, Justice Hollins, held that Watkins (the “Employee”) employment was terminated for just cause despite Willow Park Golf Course Ltd. (the “Employer”) not conducting an adequate investigation of the verbal and sexual harassment complaints received about the Employee from one of his direct subordinates. The Defendant maintained the conduct to be so egregious that it warranted summary termination without the need for investigation or the possibility of rehabilitation.

Justice Hollins said admission made by the Employee or allegations otherwise proven in the course of trial were sufficient to justify termination of employment and maintained that the results would have been no different if an adequate investigation would have taken place prior to termination.

There is no fixed rule as to when an employee’s conduct will justify a summary termination of employment. The proper analysis is a contextual one in which the Court assesses the degree of misconduct and the surrounding circumstances of its particular case. Determining whether misconduct in any particular case has reached a level to justify summary termination will always be fact-specific but even more so when the allegations of misconduct relate to verbal and sexual harassment. Summary dismissal will be justified when the impugned conduct violates an essential condition of the employment contract, is fundamentally or directly inconsistent with the employee’s obligations to his employer or destroys the mutual faith necessary for the employment relationship. There is no real legal debate that in cases of proven harassment of a subordinate, regardless of how serious, an employer is within its rights and arguably required to act. The only question is what type of discipline is justified in view of the circumstances, including the type, duration or nature of the harassment.

Client Testimonials

Was referred here by legal aid but very impressed. Very efficient, will use them again for legal needs.

Alison J.

Had the pleasure of working with Alya Nazareli, she was timely and always on top of things. In the end she got me exactly the result I requested... plus more.. great work Alya, I truly appreciate your hard work and dedication to my matter.

Levi B.

Great corporate lawyer team! Friendly, knowledgeable, and takes the time to get to know their clients before the $ clock starts.

List Auto

Very helpful. Friendly and professional service. Thank you.

Ange L.

Jon was always prompt in his response time. He displayed high level of knowledge and professionalism in dealing with both our real estate transactions as well as our corporation. Thank you!

Raegan T.

We worked with Jon Ablett. In addition to being prompt, flexible, and organized, he did a great job of explaining the legal details of all our cases. The service we receive from Jon Ablett and Quarry Park Law is consistently thorough and efficient. The staff have been a pleasure to work with and we would recommend them for real estate and business law in particular.

Robin C.

I wish to acknowledge the professionalism, and support that we have received from Alya Nazarali. Alya was there to educate and advise us each step of the way in our legal matters. I appreciated the way Alya took the time to understand our situation and built our case by negotiating, and mediating positively on my behalf with a purpose to continually move progress forward. I recommend Alya and Quarry Park Law to anyone seeking fair and professional legal representation with family law matters.

Nicola P.

Professional and effective service. I would like to take this chance to thank Alex for legal advise on a business matter & Jonathan for the smooth transition on the sale and purchase of our homes and coming all the way to Edmonton!
Quarry Park Lawyers made me impressed by how professional and knowledgeable they are. I highly recommend this firm, whether it's a real estate matter or a business (corporate) matter. Again, thank you Alex & Jonathan!

Michelle P.

Recently worked with Alya. I was extremely impressed with the results we got. She was very accommodating and very patient with all my questions. Will definitely come back for any future legal needs.

Matt D.

Jon at QPL was very helpful with the closing of my house sale - very efficient!

Marlisa A.

This is the third time I've used Jonathan Ablett for buying or selling a house. The first time was three and a half years ago, then this past month he helped with the home we sold and then the house we just bought. He is very professional, makes an effort to have a flexible schedule, always works in your best interest, and will answer every question you have. I recommend him to anyone requiring a lawyer for property reasons.

Jordan M.